Can we Compromise on Abortion?


A friend who knows my pro-life position gave me a CD of a talk given by talk show host Dennis Prager and asked me to listen to it. Since I’m a regular listener to his show, I listened to this tape with interest. The title of the talk was “Abortion – The Case for Compromise.” Prager is a very insightful person and his arguments are always well reasoned. His premise was that a compromise could be reached between the far left, who thinks that the fetus is equivalent to a decayed tooth and the right who believes that abortion is murder. Prager said that since he is neither to the left nor to the right of this issue, he was the perfect person to argue for a compromise.

Prager made a compelling case for his position which he supported with evidence he found in his research for the talk and even the Bible. He argues that both the left and the right are wrong. The left is wrong because they equate the unborn baby with a decayed tooth and the right is wrong for calling abortion murder. Prager uses an example of calls he gets on the radio when discussing the abortion issue. In one particular instance, to prove his point that abortion cannot be compared to murder, he asks the person making this claim whether he/she believes that doctors who perform abortions should be prosecuted and jailed for murder. I found his arguments less than convincing.

I have one simple question: if the unborn is a human being, and we know that it is, when can a human being be killed and not be murder? Now if you’re talking about the death penalty exercised by the legal authority of the state, then I agree, the death of an inmate killed by the authority of the state that tried him and found him/her guilty of a crime punishable by death is not murder. The dictionary defines murder as “the unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another.” I will argue that the capricious decision of someone to kill an unborn human being qualifies as murder. The willful taking of a human life by abortion which can be done at the will of a person for no reason, or any reason, such as she’s not ready for motherhood, or the pregnancy interferes with her career or a planned vacation is plain murder according to the earlier definition.

In my college logic class we learned about the syllogism. A syllogism consists of two premises and a conclusion. In order for the conclusion to be true, both premises must be true, so, for example, all dogs are animals, all animals have four legs, therefore all dogs have four legs is a true statement. Likewise, the killing of an innocent human being is murder, the unborn fetus is an innocent human being, and therefore the killing of an unborn is murder. Facts are stubborn things. How can you wiggle out of this? The pro-abortion followers do it all the time, but they lack any logic or reason to their argument. All they can offer is baseless platitudes, such as “a woman has a right to do with her body as she wants.” Unfortunately our culture has bought into it without ever knowing what they have bought into. Even more tragic, our fellow Christians have bought it. The Nazis had a saying that a lie repeated 100 times would become the truth to those who repeat it. Our culture has repeated the lie of abortion as “a woman’s right to choose” and now believe it as if was true.

As Scott Klusendorf, one of the most eloquent defenders of the unborn says, there is really only one question to ask regarding the evil of abortion: What is the unborn? If the unborn is the same as a decaying tooth then any woman has the right to do whatever she wants. But, if the unborn is a human being there is no way you can compromise. Truth or morality cannot and should not be compromised.

Compromise is a wonderful idea in the right context. We must compromise all the time, with our mates, our friends, even our enemies, but when it comes to moral values such the evil of abortion there can be no compromise. To compromise on moral truths is the same as watering down the truth to fit certain situations or to please some people who have a different view of abortion. In his farewell address President George W. Bush said: “But good and evil are present in this world, and between the two of them there can be no compromise.” I have no doubt that abortion is one of the greatest evil of our day. There can be no compromise between good and evil – never.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Can we Compromise on Abortion?

  1. Thanks, Russ, for the refresher on logic. It was one of my favorite classes in college. I, too, agree that it is sorely missing in the thinking of so many people, today. Perhaps it has gone out of style and being illogical is “in”. Excuse me for being a little flip at such serious time in our political times.

  2. I agree Russ. There is no compromise on this.
    Now we have the ability to save fetuses that are under 500 grams. Just 30 years ago, that was unheard of. Eventually we will be able to maintain viability of a fetus, outside the womb for the entire duration. How can we say it isn’t human life, even by scientific terms.
    But I must say that for me, capital punishment is also as evil as abortion.
    Jesus teaches this as he saves a woman from being stoned to death. When the Jewish leaders attempted to carry out the death penalty Jesus said, anyone who has never sinned could cast the first stone. By this Jesus was saying that sin is sin. And in God’s eyes everyone is guilty. Jesus says clearly in his teachings that we have no right to judge and condemn others.
    I am amazed at the number of people who have been on death row and exonerated through DNA testing. Imagine the number of people who have been executed who were innocent. There is so much corruption in the criminal system.
    But capital punishment would still be evil if these issues didn’t exist. Capital punishment is revenge, it’s not punishment.
    The Lord says. “Vengeance is Mine.”
    Once someone is dead, there is no way for that person to repent and give their life back to God. The State has taken away that chance. That is something that man is not allowed to do. It is reserved for the Creator, not the creature.

    Blessings to you and your family,

    April Marano

  3. April is right in saying that Capital punishment is wrong. Her scripture quotations were well put. However Abortion trumps Capital Punishment. Those held in prison for commited crimes made choices along the way that led them down this pathway and have the right of defense. An unborn infant has no choices. They are helpless and voiceless. They are killed with the protection of the law with no defense. Those who support this philosophy are cooperators in the culture of death. Pope John Paul ii and Pope Benedict XVI have warned us what dire consequences abortion and euthanasia would bring: death and destruction of not only the body but the soul as well. We must welcome Christ into our hearts with the desire and hope that He will find us worthy when He comes again.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s